Peer Reviewer Process

Proses Penelaahan (Reviewing Process)

Dalam proses penelaahan, setiap naskah akan dinilai oleh minimal dua orang penelaah (reviewer) yang memiliki keahlian sesuai dengan topik penelitian. Apabila terdapat dua penelaah, pertimbangan dari penelaah pertama akan menjadi prioritas utama bagi editor dalam mengambil keputusan akhir.

Setiap penelaah diberikan waktu dua minggu sampai dua bulan untuk menyelesaikan satu putaran proses penelaahan. Hasil revisi dari penulis harus menanggapi seluruh komentar penelaah sebelumnya, serta menunjukkan dengan jelas bahwa naskah telah direvisi sesuai masukan yang diberikan.

Pemilihan Penelaah

Calon penelaah dipilih berdasarkan reputasi akademik, baik di tingkat nasional maupun internasional, yang dinilai dari jumlah publikasi ilmiah serta kualitas penelitian yang pernah dilakukan.
Selanjutnya, editor akan mengirimkan surat undangan resmi kepada setiap calon penelaah.

Setelah calon penelaah menyatakan kesediaannya, editor akan membuat akun penelaah pada sistem Open Journal System (OJS) dan mengirimkan naskah melalui platform tersebut.

Sistem Penelaahan

Seluruh proses penelaahan dilakukan menggunakan sistem penelaahan ganda tertutup (double-blind review), di mana identitas penulis dan penelaah dirahasiakan satu sama lain.
Seluruh proses ini dikelola sepenuhnya oleh editor melalui OJS.

Kebijakan Naskah

Artikel hanya akan dipertimbangkan untuk diterbitkan apabila belum pernah dipublikasikan sebelumnya dan tidak sedang diajukan untuk publikasi di tempat lain.

Reviewing Process

During the reviewing process, each manuscript will be evaluated by at least two reviewers who have expertise relevant to the research topic.
If two reviewers are assigned, the consideration from the first reviewer will serve as the primary reference for the editor in making the final decision.

Each reviewer is given a period of two weeks to two months to complete one round of review.
The revised manuscript submitted by the author must address all reviewer comments and clearly demonstrate that revisions have been made in accordance with the feedback provided.

Reviewer Selection

Prospective reviewers are selected based on their academic reputation, both nationally and internationally, as reflected in the number and quality of their scientific publications and research experience.
Subsequently, the editor will send an official invitation letter to each potential reviewer.

Once the reviewer confirms their availability, the editor will create a reviewer account in the Open Journal System (OJS) and send the manuscript through the platform.

Review System

The entire review process is conducted using a double-blind review system, in which the identities of both authors and reviewers are kept confidential from each other.
All stages of the review process are fully managed by the editor through the OJS platform.